Is Brady Olson the Best Quarterback in the NEC?

Heading into the season, the battle for best quarterback in the NEC was a two man race. Now that race has expanded a little, but the leader in the clubhouse was probably not one we saw coming.

Brady Olson isn’t a new figure to the NEC or college football. The Massachusetts product (and transfer, for that matter) has been playing in Division I since 2021. With that kind of backlog of games to look through, you can forgive us all for thinking that Olson kind of was who he was at this point.

In 2024, he was okay. I wish I knew a better way to describe his performance. He threw for 17 touchdowns to 12 interceptions and 51.1% accuracy. The key to CCSU’s offense was obviously Elijah Howard, and the offensive line that the Blue Devils sported last year would have led you to believe that Olson had the best possible conditions in 2024- and with that, he threw just a handful more touchdowns than interceptions. The addition of Donovan Wadley this year might help him a little, sure, but you can’t call him a game manager with those interception numbers. He’s adding just a little more than he’s taking away.

Enter 2025.

Through 6 games, he’s looked like a legitimate contender for offensive player of the year. Olson has done a whole lot more than throw touchdowns. He’s done that- he’s at 11 so far- but the real key to his improvement has been how well he’s done taking care of the ball. Again, Olson has played 6 games, including one against an FBS team. Despite that, he has thrown just one interception. One.

To me, ball security is paramount in quarterbacks. You can win the game, even with a low yards per play, if you don’t beat yourself. A punt isn’t a winning play, but it isn’t always a losing one. Not compared to desperation interceptions or fumbles from extending a play too long. So Olson has that box checked, and certainly has improved his performance from last season in that regard. But he’s done so much more than that.

Olson is now throwing 59.6%- a big jump from 51.1%. That’s an extra completion for every 10 throws. If that seems small to you, think get back to me after the next 3rd and 7 your team misses. Every little bit helps, and that’s a big jump. He’s been more accurate, but he’s not throwing for less yardage or taking strictly checkdown throws. There’s no indication at all that Olson’s been more careful with the ball by making high percentage, low upside throws. Quite the opposite, in fact. He’s taken his yards per game from 172.2 to 213. It’s not that he’s just throwing more, either. His yards per attempt has gone up a full yard from last year, too. Compare him across the board in college football, and you’ll see even more reasons for excitement. 21 quarterbacks have thrown for 1200 passing yards so far this season. Only Olson has thrown just one interception. It’s not a fluke, and it’s not something with a small sample size- obviously, on that last point. How can you play 6 games, throw 1200 yards, 11 TDs, and even argue that there’s a small sample size?

You can’t.

The cumulative statistics are great, but they’re not the whole story. This past Saturday against Sacred Heart, Olson accounted for five touchdowns. Five. He ran for one (including the 4th quarter one to put CCSU in the lead), threw for four (including the first play overtime touchdown pass), and, again, never put CCSU in a position where they could beat themselves. He’s no longer a decent player, someone we can refer to as “okay” but not in the conversation with the top quarterbacks in the league. He was serviceable. But that performance was not “serviceable.” It was not someone who doesn’t beat themselves. Olson had a running back that ran for 100 yards, but in the 4th quarter and overtime, he sure looked like someone who could- and did- put the team on his back. He refused to lose to Sacred Heart and to have a third last minute game slip through. The fire was evident after his late rushing touchdown as he headed towards the sidelines. He would not go off the field a late loser again. Olson willed the Blue Devils across the finish line. What a performance.

Coach Lechtenberg pointed out to us that what Olson achieved with that performance was the most important stat at all. “I've always asked him, how do you evaluate quarterbacks if not by winning? And he continues to prove that he can do that,” Lechtenberg said. “The thing about Brady, he's the same guy every week, whether he's playing great or playing good or whatever. He continues to play. We started three true freshmen on the O-line last week, and he didn't blink an eye. Whether things are going good or bad, he's the same person, and that's what I can appreciate about him. He's a competitor. He gives us a chance every week to win games, and I really appreciate that.”

We’re six games in. Not all of the answers are here yet. They haven’t named the first team QB yet.

But if Olson keeps playing at this level, you can’t make an argument for anyone else.